Book Review: Sudden Sea, The Great Hurricane of 1938
By: R. A. Scotti
Reviewed by: Lynn Peterson
Rating: Must Read!
Do you think that you are safe from hurricanes? Hurricanes don’t just strike places with palm trees. They can come ashore anywhere along the East and Gulf Coasts of America, even places that we do not typically think of as vulnerable, such as New England. In Sudden Sea, the Great Hurricane of 1938, R.A. Scotti tells the story of one such hurricane. It took New Englanders completely by surprise, as Scotti explains, “Hurricane was a foreign word in New England. People didn’t know how to pronounce it. They didn’t know what it meant, and whatever it meant, they were sure it couldn’t happen to them, until September 1938.”
The sad truth is that, “Most days we go along blithely unconcerned that directly over our heads is a vast, never static sea that we can’t control and only partially understand.” Nobody, not even Grady Norton and Gordon Dunn, expected that this September Cape Verde hurricane would take aim at and hit New England. They initially expected a Miami landfall, and Floridians were stocked up and prepared for the impending hurricane that never arrived. After the hurricane passed Florida by, the Weather Bureau assumed that the hurricane would travel north and curve out to sea. Steering currents were not considered, but regardless of whether people were aware of them or not, they pushed the hurricane West towards its New England landfall.
The human impact of landfalling tropical storms is tremendous, as Scotti shows through the stories of those who survived and those who did not. Especially heart-wrenching was the story of the school bus full of children that attempted to drive across the causeway connecting Jamestown to Beavertail through the steadily rising water. Two incredibly poor decisions by bus driver, Norm Caswell, led to the deaths of seven children. The first error was driving into the hubcap-deep water that caused the bus to stall. The second error was to evacuate the children from the shelter of the bus in an attempt to walk or swim to land. Human bodies, especially those of children, are no match to the force of a storm surge. Scotti explains this point very clearly, “a rugged eleven-year-old weighs maybe seventy-five or eighty pounds. One cubic yard of water weighs about three-quarters of a ton.”
It is not likely that today such a hurricane could hit the United States without warning. We have a better understanding of hurricane behavior, steering currents, and we have radar and satellite imaging to show us where storms are located. Unfortunately, all of our knowledge, and hopefully memory of history, does not make us immune to the effects of landfalling tropical storms and hurricanes. However, timely warnings, preparedness, and efficient evacuations can prevent the incredible death tolls experienced in 1938. We must not fall victim to weather amnesia. If a weather event has historically occurred at a location, it can happen again. Stotti shows that 1938 was not the first time a hurricane hit New England. She discusses the effects of the Great Colonial Hurricane of 1635 and the Great September Gale of 1815. Don’t let the lessons of the past be forgotten. Read Sudden Sea, and if you live in a hurricane risk area, which is anywhere along the Atlantic or Gulf Coasts, develop a hurricane-preparedness or evacuation plan for you and your family. You may even wish to work with local authorities to help develop plans for the community as a whole.
